Contact Form

 

Annex A-Group Research Proposal (Engineering)

SCHOOL OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY, SINGAPORE
INVESTIGATIVE SKILLS IN SCIENCE
Names:Stanley Yeo, Nicholas Soon, Kaliraj Santoshraj ,Timothy Kom
Class: S2-07
Group Reference: E 

1.    Indicate the type of research that you are adopting:

[  ] Test a hypothesis: Hypothesis-driven research
e.g. Investigation of the anti-bacteria effect of chrysanthemum

[   ] Measure a value: Experimental research (I)
e.g. Determination of the mass of Jupiter using planetary photography

[  ] Measure a function or relationship: Experimental research (II)
e.g. Investigation of the effect of temperature on the growth of crystals

] Construct a model: Theoretical sciences and applied mathematics
e.g. Modeling of the cooling curve of naphthalene 

[  ] Observational and exploratory research
e.g. Investigation of the soil quality in School of Science and Technology, Singapore  

[X] Improve a product or process: Industrial and applied research
e.g. Development of a SMART and GREEN energy system for households  






2.    Write a research proposal of your interested topic in the following format:

Title:Development of a smart lift

A. Problems being addressed
      
  In lifts we often use nowadays,we always have to press buttons to get us from one storey to the other.There are many times when we are carrying bulky items or the lift is too crowded and cannot reach for the lift buttons.It would be easier for us if we do not need to reach out and press the button.In this project,we aim to replace the buttons with another more convenient alternative.
B. Goals

In particular, we want to

(a) build the lift shaft

(b) build the lift unit

(c) wire the motor

(d)program the motor using Arduino

Specific Requirements
The lift has to be:
Efficient-achieving maximum productivity with minimum wasted effort or expense
User-friendly-Easy to use or learn to use
Reliable-Consistently good in quality or performance











Part 1 -The Lift Shaft

The Lift Shaft
1.1 The design of the shaft
1.2 Considerations of the materials to use
1.3 Consideration of suggestions
1.4 From concept to reality
1.5 Materials required
1.6 Risk and safety precautions



1.1 The design of the shaft

To begin with the development on The Smart Lift, Our group had to decide on the design of the shaft. Many questions were asked, leading to many problems. Some of these problems included how to maximise the use of space in the lift to have a larger capacity and the prevention of the the lift and counter-weight crashing onto the walls of the shaft. Lastly and most importantly, we also needed to ensure that we could do maintenance on the lift easily should there be any problem. And these were probably the smallest problems out of the many questions we asked ourselves in search of the perfect design. After thinking of possible ways the shaft should look like, we started on our initial sketches and modelling.Here is the first version of our lift shaft.

 
Figure 1.1a : Overview of shaft

 
Figure 1.1b : Side view of shaft

 
Figure 1.1c : Top view of shaft

1.2 Considerations of the use of materials

One problem was structural integrity. Afraid that the shaft would collapse under the load of the lift and counterweight, we devised an brand new idea. Our Team redesigned the whole shaft.


1.3 Suggestions and considerations

Some of our ideas include having a pulley system to give the lift a mechanical advantage. Another suggestion was to have doors at the side as an alternative to a windowed shaft. Thinking about it, having doors would be beneficial to us. It will be easier for us to install and/or replace parts easily without having to take the whole shaft apart. Having the doors will also allow people to take a look at the interior of our lift.

1.4 From concept to reality

1.4.1 Making sure that the shaft will work properly with the lift unit (Details in chapter 2)

After the lift unit had been designed, our team did some minor adjustments to both the shaft and lift unit to fit them together. The result would be A Smart Lift that will work in coordination and there will be no big problems as long as the parts fit properly without any errors. To ensure that, the lift shaft has been design at all sides to have a little leeway of about 10mm to 20mm for us to make minor adjustments.

1.4.2 Finalised sketches

As mentioned, here are our sketches.The whole lift will measure 264(mm) by 264(mm) by 74(mm).
Figure 1.4.2a : Sketch of the front panel of shaft.

 
Figure 1.4.2b : Sketch of the rest of the panels of shaft.





1.4.3 3D Modelling

After we completed the dimensions, we made a 3D model using Google Sketch-Up.
 
Figure 1.4.3a Overview of the 3D model.

Figure 1.4.3b From Top


 
Figure 1.4.3c Bottom and Side View


To download 3D model, please click here .

1.5 Materials required

Cotton string(5m)
Hinges x 4
Handle x 2

Wood(Dimensions shown in Section 1.4.2 of the proposal)

1.6 Risk and Safety precautions


Risk
Safety Precautions
We might piece the pieces together incorrectly or the dimensions might be wrong
We have to double check all dimensions and refer to the dimensions before piecing the pieces together
We might hurt ourselves when  handling sharp equipment such as penknives or saws or drills.
We must be careful and not be distracted when using saws,penknives and drills so as not to hurt ourselves.
We might get hurt when handling the shaft as the edges of the wood might be sharp or there might be splinters of wood of the shaft
Use sandpaper to make the wood smooth and free of rough edges/splinters





Part 2-The Lift Unit

2.1 Equipment
2.1.1 The Type of Lift
2.1.2 Considerations for Types of Materials to be Used
2.2 Procedures
2.2.1 Dimensions
2.2.2 Overcoming Internal Structural Problems
2.2.3 From Paper and Pen to Digital Modelling
2.2.4 Overcoming Modelling errors
2.2.5 Concept to Reality
2.2.6 Fitting of parts
2.3 Risk and safety
2.3.1 Hazards and Complications
2.4 Analysing Data
2.4.1 Brainstorming and Organising Data
2.4.2 Getting Suggestions
2.4.3 Resources Required


2.1 Equipment

2.1.1 The Type of Lift 

To start off, our group had to start decide on what type of lift to make. We had to decide on the type of lift to use, and in the end, our group decided to just design and build a conventional lift. Due to time constraints, we decided to make a conventional lift with a counter-weight. Now, we had to decide what software to use. We decided to use Arduino although it is rarely used to control a lift.Learning to program an Arduino would be much easier than programming Java. Next, we also had to think of other complications that would affect the lift and its design.

2.1.2 Considerations for Types of Materials to be Used

Next, there are other things that needs consideration as well. The type of material used had to be strong and light. Acrylic and plywood were good choices. Plywood and acrylic are both strong. The average weight of a 3mm piece of acrylic with an area of a square meter would weigh 7.5kg((usplastic.com, 2010)) and 2.3kg per square meter for 3mm plywood. Acrylic can also be translucent or transparent, depending on the type of acrylic used, which means that we can see whatever is going inside the lift although it is enclosed. Also, we can get to see the wiring behind the scenes from the outside. However, some pieces of wood would have to  be thicker than 3mm, for example 7mm.This is due to internal electronic components which need to have thicker walls to secure them to.

2.2 Procedures
Figure 2.2a Dimensions
  
 
Figure 2.2b 
























2.2.2 Overcoming Internal Structural Problems

In the interior of the lift where the buttons are, wires would be required to connect them to the Arduino. and breadboard.The breadboard is connected to a power source. Therefore, 2 panels were placed in the lift with a spacing of 2mm in between them. This will allow wires to be able to fit through easily and should have enough space for the buttons and LED wiring.To keep the lift upright and not shake while moving up and down, we also can put a rod in 2 corners so that the lift can be guided along it and not be out of alignment.

2.2.3 From Paper and Pen to Digital Modelling

 
Figure 2.2.3a
Front view of lift. The door frame which is made of acrylic(Translucent/Transparent) 
  

90 Degree and L-brackets are also used in the lift to secure the acrylic to the wood planks as the acrylic cannot be glued easily. Thus, we have used nuts and bolts to secure them together.

Screen Shot 2015-02-25 at 1.17.35 pm.png

Screen Shot 2015-02-25 at 1.10.30 pm.png

2.2.4 Overcoming errors in modelling

After all the modeling, we went through the tedious procedure of making sure every piece of the 3D model was of the correct size. Whenever we discovered an error, we redid the various designs, modules and parts such that everything would fit into the size limit of 230mm. This also included the pulley at the top.

2.2.5 Concept to Reality

Next, went to the carpenter to get the wood with the correct dimensions. For the rest of parts, we would then get the hardware online or at Sim Lim Towers or Fook Hai building.

2.2.6 Fitting of parts

After the wood is ready,we would have to glue(epoxy/Cyanoacrylates glue) and piece everything together. Then, we would put the lift in the shaft. Wiring and programming will then take place.

2.3 Risk and safety

2.3.1 Risk and Safety Precautions

Other complications include the moving of the lift from each level to the other. Since connecting only one cable to the lift and to the motor and then the counter-weight, the motor required would need to be very powerful as a lot of torque is needed. Therefore, a moveable pulley system with several wheels attached to the shaft and lift would be required to ensure that a normal motor could be able to pull the lift up and down at a reasonable speed. Thus, this would also ensure that there is more accuracy in the lift stopping at the correct location at each floor. The quality of wood used must also be considered; if the material is of not of good quality, it may snap or break. Therefore, the plywood used should be solid plywood.

Risk
Safety precaution
The friction between the stepper motor and cotton string hoisting the lift unit is not enough to hoist the lift unit upward
Use materials such as rubber on the axle of the motor to increase friction or decrease the weight of the lift by using lighter materials such as styrofoam
Positioning of stepper motor is wrong and the lift door is unaligned with the door to the lift
Ensure that the stepper motor is placed in the right position and the programming brings the lift unit to be aligned with the lift door on the shaft
Lift unit banks to one side as the centre of gravity is not in the centre
Make sure the centre of gravity is such that the lift unit is stable and does not tilt to any side at all before building the lift unit


2.4 Analysing data

2.4.1 Brainstorming and Organising Data

Ideas and procedures are important to ensure the smooth running of this part of the project. Therefore, we need to organise all the data we currently have and compile them together so no errors would happen throughout the course of this project. We have already compiled our current plans to prevent any errors.

2.4.2 Getting Suggestions

After that, we had to get suggestions to improve our current design. We needed more innovations in our lift thus got Mr Tan to give us some ideas. These included an overload sensor,sound sensor, and the replacement of the lift buttons with infrared sensors and Annikken Andee. 
The sound sensor would function by having a person in the lift state the floor he needs to go to verbally.The infrared sensors would work when someone puts an object or hand over it. Annikken Andee would allow the lift to be operated by bluetooth.These ideas would work well when the passenger’s hand is full and he cannot press the buttons. This would help him as he would not need to put everything down to control the lift.

2.4.3 Resources Required

Acrylic and wood pieces(Refer to Figures 2.2a and 2.2b for details) 
Nuts and bolts/Glue(To put together all parts)



This is all for the part 2(Lift) and will be continued in Part 3(Electronics).















Part 3-Electronics
3.1 Equipment
3.1.1 Finding the right materials
3.1.2 List of materials
3.2 Procedures
3.3 Risk and safety
3.3.1 Risks and safety precautions



3.1 Equipment

3.1.1 Finding the right materials

   With consideration of the type of lift we are about to build,the wires of the lift would have to move up and down together with the lift unit.This alone would pose many problems with the wiring of the lift.
Problem 1.We need to find the right wire that fits our needs to connect the wires to the lift unit.

Problem 2.We had to ensure that the wire we use would not obstruct the lift when the lift unit is moving.
 
Figure 3.1.1a - General layout of lift(From top)

Resolving Problem 1.
For the power cable to enter the lift shaft and connect to the lift unit,it has to be light and flexible.Such properties would allow the wire to bend as the lift unit makes its way upward and downward.This will ensure that the wire would not resist and motion of the lift unit.To solve this problem,we have found a type of power cable called jumper wire that is both light and flexible and therefore suitable for us to use.

Resolving Problem 2.
Our original plan was to drill the wire hole at the first floor(refer to figure 3.1.1b),but we decided to shift it up to the second floor(refer to figure 3.1.1c) for fear that the wire might be damaged as the lift unit rose higher and the wire had to pay out, or might obstruct the lift unit as it descended back to the first floor.The wire might not be able to fit back into the wire hole and out of the lift shaft as the lift unit reached the first floor.











Figure 3.1.1b
 



In order not to damage the wire or the lift unit as the lift moves up and down,the wire will be inserted via a hole drilled into the side of the lift shaft at the second floor.



















Figure 3.1.1c
 

3.1.2 Material List

AC to DC adapter x 1
Jumper wires
  • Packs of 80 Female to Female wire x 2
  • Packs of 80 Male to Male wire x 2

Stepper motor x 1

Color buttons x 7


3.2  Procedures

3.2.1 Connection of Lift unit to Arduino

      First,button holes of diameter 30mm would be needed to be drilled into the side of the lift shaft and also the lift unit.This would enable the buttons to be fitted outside the shaft and inside the lift unit.These buttons will then be wired to the Arduino,which will control the lift according to which buttons are pressed.We will need 7 buttons,1 on the second floor,2 on the third floor,and 1 on the fourth floor,and 3 in the lift unit.The motor will only start after a  5 second delay,allowing the user to have time to take his hand out of the lift unit so as to prevent injury or damage.

    For each of the buttons,1 pin is connected to the Arduino.The Arduino will be programmed to start the motor after the safety button has been pressed and allow the motor to reach the designated floor.In order for the lift unit to reach the designated floor,the motor that is controlled by the Arduino will be programmed to coil the wire up or down a fixed number of times.These calculations have to be very precise because we have to ensure that the lift unit is not out of place.

 Figure 3.2.1



3.2.2 Connection of Arduino to Motor

   Another problem that we encountered was that the motor could only turn in one direction.How would we be able to use the motor for both pulling in and letting out of the steel cable?The construction of the lift would be impossible if the motor could only perform one function.There would not be enough space in the shaft to place two engines.To solve this problem,we have come up with a solution on how to move the motor both clockwise and anticlockwise. 

Figure 3.2.2

This system circuit will comprise of 4 switches.We will connect each switch to 1 pin on the Arduino.The Arduino will be programmed such that when switches 1 and 3 in the diagram is closed ,the motor will turn clockwise.When switches 2 and 4 are closed,the motor will turn anti-clockwise.

3.2.3 Connection of Arduino to LED Display

    For a single digit LED display,the minimum number of pins that have to be connected to the Arduino is 9.The Arduino will be programmed to display the which floor the lift unit is currently at.

3.3 Risk and Safety

3.3.1 Risk and Safety Precautions

Risk
Safety Precaution
Electrocution when handling electrical cables
Wear rubber gloves when coming in contact with wires/electric current.
If all switches are open at the same time in Figure 3.2.2,the motor might become overloaded and break down.

We have to take precaution and label the
switches of prevent the wires being connected wrongly and the  motor failing.

Too many wires inside the shaft might result in short circuits
Use heat string(a shrinkable plastic tube used to insulate wires) to cover any exposed metal parts of wires
Wires might be connected to the wrongly and due to confusion as there are too many wires
Label the wires so that confusion can be avoided

The metal tips of the jumper wires might break off
Handle the wires with care
























Part 4-Arduino

4.1 Equipment
4.1.1 Finding the right materials
4.1.2 List of materials
4.2 Procedures
4.3 Risk and safety
4.3.1 Risks and safety precautions



4.1 Equipment list:
Arduino Uno x 1
Arduino Mega x 1
Mega Breadboard x 2
Annikken Andee x 1












4.2 Coding

 
Figure 4.2.1a

This shows a LED lighting up. This is the most basic thing when coding Arduino. 

Figure 4.2.1b
shows the coding which makes the LED switch on and off.

  

Figure 4.2.1d

Figure 4.2.1d  shows the LED light lighting up when the pushbutton is pushed.

 
Figure 4.2.1e shows the program for the the actions in  
Figure 4.2.1c and Figure 4.2.1d .

We were asked to program 12 pushbuttons and 4 LEDs such as in the diagram below. He want me to program such that when PB1, 2 or 3 is pressed LED 1 lights up. When PB4, 5, 6 is pressed LED 2 lights up. When PB7, 8 or 9 is pressed LED 3 lights up. When PB10, 11 or 12 lights up, LED 4 lights up.

 
Figure 4.2.1f
The diagram below shows the program for the task.
 
Figure 4.2.1g
 
Figure 4.2.1h

Figure 4.2.1i
 
Figure 4.2.1j
There are a lot of problems with the programming since there are many situations that the lift should work. If there are only exterior buttons, the program is much simpler. But since, there are interior and exterior buttons, the program must be coded in way such that when someone presses the button on the first floor, the lift should go to the first floor.

After research and help from my parents and uncle, I managed to program it. The code is shown below  
  







 The program for Anikken Andee is below.








5.3 Risk and safety and its precautions


Risks and Safety
Risks and Safety Precautions
There is a possibility of the person handling the arduino to be electrocuted  Wear gloves when handling Arduino.
There is a possibility of the items such as LEDs to break easily as they are fragile. Handle the items with care
There is a possibility of the person handling the parts to bleed as the end tips of the parts are sharp and scratch us. Be careful when handling the parts.





6. Bibliography
 
A model elevator. (2015). Retrieved 16 January, 2015 ,from http://www.all-science-fair-projects.com/science_fair_projects/57/696/245147ccd278284f21ff76f593804398.html

Angwin, J. (2006, November 14). Buttonless elevators have their ups and downs. Retrieved 3 March, 2015 ,from http://www.post-gazette.com/business/tech-news/2006/11/14/Buttonless-elevators-have-their-ups-and-downs/stories/200611140144

Annikken Andee. (2014). Annikken andee for android. Retrieved 2 March, 2015 ,from http://www.annikken.com/andee/

 
Annikken Andee. (Videographer) (2013). What is annikken andee? [Web]. Retrieved 23 February, 2015 , from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I7xM31hP93A

 
 Arduino simulator. (n.d.). Retrieved 12 January, 2015 , from http://123d.circuits.io/circuits/537891-the-unnamed-circuit/edit


TalkandLift. (Producer) (2009). Talk and lift - the voice controlled elevator [Web]. Retrieved 2 March, 2015 ,  from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KVSPnEYKgZU

Chilton, A. (2013, October 7). The working principle and key applications of infrared sensors. Retrieved 2 March, 2015 , from http://www.azosensors.com/Article.aspx?ArticleID=339

Fischetti, M. (2008, December 15). How do elevators work?. Retrieved 19 February, 2015, from http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-do-elevators-work/

ganzeige. (Videographer) (2010). ◢elevator with automatic doors◤ [lego] [Web]. Retrieved 9 February , 2015, from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J8nTT4FvnxQ

GJETA, A., TARELLI, P., & HASANAJ, A. (2010).Elevator model. Unpublished raw data, Faculty of Mechanical Engineering, University Polytechnic of Tirana , Tirana, Tirana,Albania. Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3hZk3MZ5-Oo     -    Video of the modeling of an elevator

Learn Engineering. (Videographer) (2014). Dc motor, how it works? [Web]. Retrieved February 16, 2015, from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LAtPHANEfQo

Marco, C. (2011, April 15). Connecting a unipolar stepper to arduino. Retrieved 20 February, 2015, from http://www.betasix.net/connecting-a-unipolar-stepper-to-arduino/

MrVideodude709. (Videographer) (2013). a look at a awesome otis elevator [Web]. Retrieved 16 February, 2015, from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dbS4oQnqdWs

NDStamsta. (2013, March 18). Re: Controlling stepper motor position w/ push buttons [Online forum comment]. Retrieved 12 February, 2015, from http://forum.arduino.cc/index.php?topic=155022.0

pcbheaven. (Videographer) (2010). How the stepper motors are made and how they operate - part 2[Web]. Retrieved 16 February, 2015, from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t-3VnLadIbc

ralle, P. (Videographer) (2013). Model elevator[Web]. Retrieved February 24, 2015, from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V3h7loSDEI0            

Rubin, J. (2013, June). Find out how elevators work using pulleys. Retrieved February 19, 2015, from http://www.projects.juliantrubin.com/science_fair_project/engineering/pulley_1.html

Shuk Yee, C., Ka Chun, K., Chun Wa, K., San Tat Alexander, L., Chun Pong, N., Tsz Hin Simon, T., & Kin Ming, W. (2007). Siemens intelligent lift model. Retrieved January 28, 2015, from http://mmu.ic.polyu.edu.hk/mu_proj/2007/M3/index.htm     -    Reference site-SIEMENS intelligent lift model

Techie, H. (n.d.). **experiment 5: Push buttons** . Retrieved 14 February, 2015, from https://learn.sparkfun.com/tutorials/sik-experiment-guide-for-arduino---v32/experiment-5-push-buttons        


Tom, H. (2002, February 12). How elevators work. Retrieved 6 March , 2015,from http://science.howstuffworks.com/transport/engines-equipment/elevator.htm
               
Ulas, U. D. (Videographer) (2013). Arduino simple elevator project [Web]. Retrieved 13 February, 2015 , from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7UgeeRa5jX0


usplastic.com. (2010, October 12). How much do the acrylic sheets weigh?. Retrieved 3 February, 2015 , from http://www.usplastic.com/knowledgebase/article.aspx?contentkey=884


Wikipedia. (2015, February 26). Elevator. Retrieved 7 February, 2015 , from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elevator


Woodford, C. (2014, May 16). Elevators. Retrieved 13 January, 2015 , from http://www.explainthatstuff.com/how-elevators-work.html
 








Total comment

Author

Kom Weng Ern Timothy

0   comments

Cancel Reply